Outcry Over 'Boys II Planet' Judges' Comments on Contestants' Weight

In recent weeks, Mnet's survival show 'Boys II Planet' has come under fire for allegedly promoting harmful body standards through comments made by its judges regarding contestants' weight and appearance. This criticism has ignited a debate about the pressures of body image within the K-pop industry, particularly as it pertains to the mental health of young performers.

The controversy began during a recent episode aired on July 25, 2025, where judges, including Jaejoong and Baek Gu Young, made remarks that many viewers interpreted as fat-shaming. Jaejoong commented on a contestant's performance, stating, "I felt your [old] age through both your performance and your visuals. I think that this should not be the case," implying that the contestant's physique negatively impacted their on-stage abilities. Baek Gu Young further added that the contestants could improve their performances if they "tidy up [their] physique a little."

Social media erupted with backlash against the judges, with many fans expressing outrage over their comments, arguing that such remarks perpetuate outdated beauty standards and contribute to mental health issues among young idols. One Twitter user remarked, "You’re good at dancing but you’d be better if you weren’t fat and also you’re kind of ugly," reflecting the harsh criticism aimed at the judges' standards.

Conversely, some defended the judges, arguing that comments linking weight to performance are common in the competitive world of K-pop, where agility and physical fitness are often seen as integral to success. Supporters of the judges contended that the remarks were not directly fat-shaming but rather aimed at encouraging improvement within a highly competitive environment.

The ongoing debate highlights a broader issue within the entertainment industry, where mental health and body image continue to be contentious topics. According to Dr. Lisa Thompson, a psychologist specializing in body image issues at the University of Southern California, "The pressure to conform to societal beauty standards can lead to severe mental health consequences, including anxiety and depression among young performers."

As 'Boys II Planet' progresses, many are questioning the show's ability to maintain credibility in light of these criticisms. The potential ramifications of such comments extend beyond individual contestants, influencing the broader conversation about the treatment of idols in the K-pop industry. The show's production team has yet to issue an official response to the backlash, leaving fans and commentators eager for clarification on how they plan to address these concerns moving forward.

In conclusion, the incident surrounding 'Boys II Planet' serves as a reminder of the critical need for sensitivity and awareness regarding body image issues in entertainment. As the industry evolves, it is imperative to foster an environment that prioritizes the well-being of artists over outdated standards of beauty.