Review of 'Sing Street': A Heartfelt Musical Journey in 1980s Dublin

The stage adaptation of John Carney’s acclaimed film, 'Sing Street', premiered at the Lyric Hammersmith in London on July 20, 2025. This musical, set against the backdrop of 1980s Dublin, intertwines themes of youthful aspiration, familial discord, and the harsh realities of economic strife. The production, which features original music by Carney and Gary Clark, depicts a group of teenagers who form a band in hopes of winning over their crushes amid their struggles with poverty and familial instability.

The narrative follows Conor, portrayed by Sheridan Townsley, a 16-year-old navigating the tumultuous waters of adolescence while dealing with his arguing parents and a brother, Larry (Harry Curley), who offers sage but somber guidance. The ensemble cast also includes Tateyana Arutura as Anne, whose character grapples with the pressure of being the shining star among her siblings.

Despite its engaging soundtrack filled with hits from iconic bands like Duran Duran and A-ha, the adaptation has been criticized for its inability to fully capture the depth of the original film. According to Arifa Akbar, the reviewer from The Guardian, the production attempts to maintain a bright and uplifting tone, which detracts from the darker elements of the storyline, including themes of economic migration and bullying. Akbar describes the script by Enda Walsh as "spare and thuddingly simplistic," noting that while the musical numbers are energetic and well-executed, the character development lacks the nuance required to resonate deeply with the audience.

The direction by Rebecca Taichman blends naturalism with theatrical flair, but critics argue that the balance may undermine the story's emotional impact. The first half of the show introduces the band’s formation and their various attempts to craft a unique image, while the second half culminates in a vibrant concert scene that showcases the performers' vocal talents. Grace Collender, who plays Raphina, Conor's love interest, receives particular praise for her strong vocal performance, which adds a layer of emotional depth to the show.

As the production continues its run at the Lyric Hammersmith until August 23, 2025, it remains a testament to the power of music and youth. However, it also serves as a reminder of the complexities of growing up against a backdrop of adversity. The nostalgic soundtrack and heartfelt performances offer a glimpse into the resilience of youth, even as the production grapples with balancing joy and sorrow in its portrayal of 1980s Dublin.

In conclusion, 'Sing Street' provides an uplifting experience through its musical numbers and performances, yet it leaves audiences yearning for a more profound exploration of its characters and themes. With its vibrant energy and catchy score, the show captures the spirit of the era, but it ultimately raises questions about the depth of storytelling in musical adaptations.