New Insights into Neanderthal Diet: The Role of Maggots and Fermented Meat

Recent research sheds light on the dietary habits of Neanderthals, challenging long-held perceptions of their eating behaviors. Traditionally viewed as predominantly carnivorous, new evidence suggests that Neanderthals were not solely reliant on meat, but may have incorporated a variety of food sources, including maggots, into their diets. This study, led by anthropologist Melanie Beasley from Purdue University, utilized stable nitrogen isotope analysis to reconstruct the diets of Neanderthals during the late Pleistocene epoch, approximately 11,700 to 129,000 years ago.

The research reveals that the nitrogen isotope ratios found in Neanderthal bones indicate an unexpectedly high intake of nitrogen-15, typically associated with apex predators. However, according to Dr. Beasley, the elevated nitrogen levels may not solely be attributed to high meat consumption. Instead, they could be influenced by the inclusion of maggots, which are nutrient-dense and easily obtainable after animal kills. "Maggots can be a fat-rich source of food and may have been a significant component of the Neanderthal diet," stated Dr. Beasley.

To investigate this hypothesis, Beasley and her team repurposed a dataset originally collected for forensic anthropology, examining how nitrogen values change during decomposition. Their findings indicated that maggots feeding on decomposing tissue showed significantly higher δ¹⁵N values, ranging from 5.4 permil to 43.2 permil, compared to typical herbivores, whose values are estimated between 0.9 permil to 11.2 permil. This suggests that the consumption of maggots could notably contribute to the high δ¹⁵N values observed in Neanderthal remains.

The study reflects a broader shift in understanding ancient hominin diets. According to Dr. John Speth, a collaborator on the study, there is historical evidence that certain Indigenous Arctic peoples valued putrid or maggot-infested meat as a delicacy. This cultural perspective may provide clues to Neanderthal dietary practices, indicating they might have engaged in similar behaviors, viewing decomposed foods as nutritious rather than unappetizing. Dr. Speth noted, "Indigenous peoples often allow meat to decompose to enhance its flavor and nutritional content."

However, while this research highlights the potential significance of maggots in Neanderthal diets, several questions remain unanswered. For instance, the exact quantity of maggots needed to account for the observed δ¹⁵N values is still uncertain. Further experimental studies are necessary to explore the nutritional benefits of consuming maggots in the context of food storage and preparation practices typical of ancient hominins.

In conclusion, the research conducted by Beasley and her colleagues not only redefines the Neanderthal diet but also emphasizes the importance of interdisciplinary approaches in understanding prehistoric lifestyles. As anthropologists continue to delve into ancient diets, the role of culturally significant practices, such as the consumption of maggots, will undoubtedly enrich our comprehension of how early humans adapted to their environments, utilized available resources, and engaged in complex food practices. The implications of this research extend beyond dietary reconstruction, offering insights into the cultural and social behaviors of our ancient relatives, which are crucial for understanding the evolutionary pathways of hominins.

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.