Brandon Smith Faces Extended Injury Layoff, Confirms Wayne Bennett

In a disheartening turn of events for the South Sydney Rabbitohs, coach Wayne Bennett announced that newly acquired hooker Brandon Smith is set for another extended stint on the sidelines due to a fresh medial collateral ligament (MCL) injury. The setback occurred during Smith’s club debut on July 6, 2025, in a match against the Manly Sea Eagles, when he fell awkwardly in a potential hip drop tackle executed by prop Matt Lodge in the 75th minute of the game. Bennett confirmed during the post-match press conference that Smith's recovery would require an estimated six to eight weeks, marking a significant blow for both the player and the team.

The Rabbitohs had high expectations for Smith, who had only recently returned from an eight-month rehabilitation period following a severe anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) and MCL rupture sustained in the final round of the 2024 season, also resulting from a hip drop tackle. This latest injury not only frustrates the coaching staff but also highlights the ongoing concerns regarding player safety and the prevalence of certain tackle techniques within the National Rugby League (NRL).

According to Bennett, “He’s done a medial ligament; he will be six to eight weeks from that tackle.” The coach expressed his frustration regarding the team's injury woes, stating, “We are not playing with a lot of luck... you make your own opinion on it.” Despite the injury setback, Bennett noted that Smith remained optimistic, saying, “I think he’s pretty happy that it’s only six to eight weeks, not eight months so he can see the light at the end of the tunnel.”

Jack Wighton, the Rabbitohs’ captain, also acknowledged Smith’s positive impact on the team since his mid-season arrival, stating, “He’s been great around the place; he has brought that energy, he’s brought the competitive nature.” Wighton reflected on his own performance during the match, suggesting that he could have better directed the team in the first half.

The Rabbitohs' current situation comes as they grapple with inconsistency in their performance, having lost to the Sea Eagles 30-12. As the team navigates this challenging period, they will need to reassess their strategies and rely on their remaining players to step up in Smith’s absence. The ongoing injuries raise questions about the effectiveness of player safety protocols and the need for potential reforms in tackle regulations within the league.

This incident underscores the increasing scrutiny on tackle techniques like the hip drop, which has gained attention for its potential to cause severe injuries. As discussions around player safety continue, the NRL may face pressure to implement stricter regulations to mitigate risks associated with such tackles. The Rabbitohs will now look to regroup and prepare for their upcoming matches, with hopes of minimizing further injury setbacks as they aim for success in the 2025 NRL season.