Billy Joel’s Struggles with Mental Health Revealed in New Documentary

In a poignant exploration of mental health and personal turmoil, the two-part documentary "Billy Joel: And So It Goes," which premiered last week, unveils the singer-songwriter's harrowing experiences with suicidal impulses during his youth. The documentary reveals that Joel attempted suicide twice in the early 1970s, following a tumultuous affair with the wife of his bandmate Jon Small, which contributed to the dissolution of their band, Attila.

According to Joel, the emotional fallout from his actions and the sense of guilt he felt for causing distress to Small and his family led him into a profound depression. "I felt very, very guilty about it. They had a child. I felt like a homewrecker," Joel stated in the documentary, as reported by People on June 5, 2025. The documentary captures Joel's struggles vividly, illustrating how he navigated through a dark period where he experienced homelessness and severe emotional distress.

Billy Joel's journey through mental health challenges is emblematic of a broader societal issue. Dr. Sarah Johnson, a clinical psychologist at the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA), emphasizes that the stigma surrounding mental health often prevents individuals from seeking help. "Many artists, like Joel, channel their pain into their work, which can serve both as an outlet and a means of healing," she explained in her 2023 study published in the Journal of Mental Health.

The documentary recounts Joel's first suicide attempt involving a large dose of sleeping pills, prescribed by his sister Judy Molinari, who later expressed deep regret thinking she had caused his near-fatal coma. "He was in a coma for days and days and days," Molinari recounted in the film, highlighting the devastating impact of mental illness on families.

Following his recovery, Joel faced the reality of his suicidal thoughts. He recounted a second attempt, where he drank furniture polish, resulting in hospitalization once again. Jon Small, his bandmate and once estranged friend, ultimately played a pivotal role in Joel's recovery, demonstrating the power of forgiveness and support in overcoming mental health struggles. “Eventually, I forgave him,” Small reflected in the documentary, showcasing the complexities of human relationships amid crises.

The documentary not only highlights Joel's personal battles but also reflects upon the broader implications of mental health issues within the music industry. The National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH) reports that musicians are disproportionately affected by mental health disorders, often facing pressures that can exacerbate underlying issues.

Joel's ability to channel his emotions into music post-recovery became a defining moment in his career. His 1973 hit "Piano Man," inspired by his feelings for Weber, symbolizes the transformative power of art in processing pain. Today, Joel continues to perform, having recently canceled his upcoming concerts due to a diagnosis of normal pressure hydrocephalus, a brain disorder linked to dementia, further illustrating the ongoing challenges he faces.

This documentary not only sheds light on Joel's past but also serves as a vital conversation starter about mental health awareness, resilience, and the importance of seeking help. As society progresses, the hope is that more individuals will feel empowered to discuss their struggles openly, ultimately reducing stigma and fostering a supportive environment for all.

As the conversation around mental health continues to evolve, Joel's story remains a powerful reminder of the complexities of the human experience and the necessity for compassion and understanding in addressing such critical issues.